Ordinary and Necessary
Friday, June 26th, 2009Before we venture into today’s topic, I need to make something perfectly clear. When owning any business and using portions of that business for tax deductions, you need to consult a CPA on what can and can not be used as a deduction with the IRS. I’ve written several articles over the years on the possible advantages of owning a home based business when it comes to taxes. We’ve always considered our experience with YTB a business and have treated it as such from the very beginning. For us, owning a business requires added responsibilities, and additional checks and balances that come with the territory.
Using a CPA the last four years when filing our taxes is part of that responsibility.
What I have also come to realize from talking with and communicating on various forms, blogs, and social networking sites is this: Not everyone feels the same type of responsibility, or has the same understanding about tax deductions and the role of the IRS.
Average individuals will make claims of what you can and can not deduct based on what they perceive to be true, or what they’ve heard is legal or illegal. I would advise in this case that you either thank them politely or simply tell them to go pound sand. (I’d prefer the later for some individuals) Unless you consult a CPA, I’d be suspect of anything you read or hear when it comes to deductions, taxes and the IRS.
We’re all very well aware of the industries fascination with YTB. Not a week goes by without some trade magazine, news publication or both publishing something about YTB. As predicted, there has been plenty of kicking and screaming this week from those few critics I spoke about surrounding Travel Weekly’s Power List publication. It looks as if the same tired old questions will continue and excuses will persist for another year. If you question why there has been no resolution to the questions and the excuses after three years of debate, it’s not really about resolution. It’s about keeping the questions active for as long as possible in order to keep their own perceptions about YTB and its place as a second (third, fourth, fifth) rate host agency alive.
Granted, a resolution would end that game, but so would the daily participation on blogs, forums, and daily discussions which take up so much of thier time. By simply asking (and never resolving) these same tired questions, they are able to deflect the attention to someone or something else instead of looking at their own issues or looking a solution.
Another question that keeps popping up, but never seems to get resolved in our industry are taxes. Apparently if you are not involved in a Home Based Business, you are not aware of the literally hundreds of sources available that provide information on the tax benefits of owning a business like YTB. Yesterday, Mark Murphy with Travel Pulse brought up a situation that questions a broader effect tied to how a traditional travel business is perceived by the IRS. He writes:
Could the proliferation of travel hobbyists, who are in it for the “free travel” perks, be part of the problem? That’s a question being raised by Gawne and other legitimate agents around the country. The challenge comes down to distinguishing between someone who is running a travel business and someone who is simply trying to run around the world, albeit at a discounted or tax-deductible rate. Where does the line get drawn?
The disconnect here is the term “hobbyist”. A word used to paint a picture because of the MLM arm and the misconceptions and myths surrounding it. It’s not about travel for them, it’s about all the recruiting. Because of the ignorance, Mark and others do not consider my business anything more than a “hobby” and therefore I do not qualify for deductions as any other business would. Unfortunately for everyone who paints this picture they fail to realize that the tax code does not specify, nor is the IRS responsible for determining proper deductions because one is a traditional business and the other is an MLM business.
The editorial came very close but never mentions the term “profit motive” which would go a long way in clearing things up. “Profit Motive” is actually what the IRS looks at. But few are willing to accept the anyone in YTB can actually make a profit using the YTB business model.
Jeff Miller, a travel attorney in Maryland who is also a columnist for Agent@Home magazine helped specify for everyone that the IRS looks at deductions as “ordinary and necessary” as part of it’s qualification. According to Jeff, the types of expenses involved such as FAM’s are legitimate business deductions based upon the type of business activity conducted. Since YTB sells the same type of travel as any other agency would, I have my doubts that the IRS would make any type of distinction between the two business models simply because one has an MLM arm and one does not.
If, and this is a really big “if” here: If the IRS does consider YTB nothing more than “hobbyists” who pose as “travel agents” and we are using travel as a deduction, the industry has no one to blame but themselves for blowing this whistle. I’ve seen countless posts, blogs, and forums that not only link to the IRS but instruct anyone with a keyboard and internet connection with how to report what they believe to be improper deductions. As a result, there could be an entire class of occupation (Travel Agent) that is now a red flag for the IRS to investigate further. Their own fears, phobias, and misconceptions surrounding our business model and desperate attempts to rid their precious industry via any means they can think of is more than likely the reason if this is in fact the case.
Again, it’s doubtful that the IRS is actually doing this. But once again, the industries focus on what they perceive to be the problem not the solution would be the reason for any red flag here. Unless the IRS has a listing of which agency is MLM and which is traditional, there is no way you an expect the IRS to not lump everyone into the same category.
If some of these traditionalists would educate themselves and actually participate in the vast amount of webinars and courses available surrounding tax deductions and whats required to claim and document the deductions it would certainly help in resolving their issue. Mark did go as far as checking with someone who is actually qualified, but doesn’t appear to make any connection with what’s legal and ethical because he can’t get past an MLM stereotype, which Mark and others apparently have determined as unethical.
Using the IRS is nothing more than a ploy to cast doubt and fear when it comes to Travel MLM’s. Mind you, the traditional agent in question here should be able to document legitimate business deductions based upon the type of business activity he is involved with. A qualified CPA can address the issues directly with the IRS and explain how this is ordinary and necessary in the travel industry. As a result, the IRS will allow the deductions.
No harm, no foul.
So why is this even a concern? It’s not.
It is however another example of ordinary myths and misconception and the actions they feel are necessary to feed the anger and resentment towards YTB and Travel MLMs.
PS - If you're involved with YTB, sign up for our FREE Newsletter. As a Website Owner or Website Seller, we'll keep you up to date with all the latest news, acquisitions, and developments with YTB.
PPS - Subscribe to the Just Picture It Now RSS feed, (including e-mail) for all the latest posts and updates found right here!
|
|
|
Doug & Ronda Bauknight AKA: TravelPro Travel Agent / Networker Phone: 678.458.5812 |
Learn How To Become A Travel Agent![]() |
Book Your Travel & Vacations With ![]() |
Do You ZamZuu?![]() |
| TSO #588629 |




One of the most surprising things I found was that the IRS does not require you to actually make a profit in order to write off these expenses, you simply need to be in “pursuit” of a profit. How cool is that?!


I then ran into the 








